那項運動最常有球證誤判

herothree

球證誤判非常發生
往往都係球賽的關鍵

As 科技進步
很多sport都有replay
但不是全部都會影響原判

Basketball and Hockey both use replay
(nba, quite 近期先用, ie:  reggie miller 3pt after the buzzer)
(american football is ALL base on replay)(almost)

but Soccer and baseball is all base on the referee's and umpire's call
replays are for fans only, no effect
(ie:  馬立當拿's classic "上帝之手")

公平嗎???

vote:  如題


昨天因一個球證誤判
使天使白白輸咗俾白襪 (MLB, Baseball)

(transfer)
九局下兩人出局情況下，白襪與天使依然戰成1-1平，皮里斯基(A.J. Pierzynski)遭到天使救援投手艾斯柯巴(Kelvim Escobar)的一記低球三振。但是當天使捕手保羅(Josh Paul)將球丟到地上與其他防守球員走回休息區準備進入延長賽時，皮里斯基卻快步衝上無人防守的一壘。

主審埃丁斯(Doug Eddings)裁定捕手保羅接到球前球已觸地，意味著天使必須將皮里斯基觸殺或者封殺在一壘前。

「我沒有聽到他(主審埃丁斯)判我出局，」皮里斯基說。「我當時認為球一定觸地了...我正準備回休息區，但發現捕手沒有觸殺我，所以我就開始跑。」

「我突然動念並決定跑壘。如果他當時觸殺我，我就出局了。」

天使主帥和多名球員對此次判罰決出異議，但無法推翻，而更糟糕的事情隨之而來。

代跑歐蘇納(Pablo Ozuna)稍後盜至二壘，而克里德敲出個人本場的第二支二壘安打，護送隊友返壘得分。

herothree

本人唔鍾意靠replay
球員有本事"老点" ref and ump.
係佢哋o既"技術"
more dramatic, 戲劇性D

(雖然有時自己鐘意嘅球隊輸becoz of that, but 冇辨法, part of the game)

Gretzky

I think baseball and football (not the American one) are the two pro sports.

Base-running are hard to call (safe or out) and outsides and fouls aren't easy either.

The ChiSox/Angels game was awful! I can't believe we have such day-dreaming referee!

甘國武

即使 Baseketball 和 Football 得票較多
也不能證明它們誤判較多
只能證明它們較多人認識

wer

Originally posted by 甘國武 at 2005-10-14 14:05:
即使 Baseketball 和 Football 得票較多
也不能證明它們誤判較多
只能證明它們較多人認識

agree

shaqkobe

NBA。節奏實在太快太快。好難真係睇得清清楚楚。

chicken

Only soccer is still use old method to judge,
and in soccer every midjudge make bigger impact rather other sports
as there are very few goals in soccer matches.

herothree

let's talk abt the WORST miss call then (any sport)

personally think it's the "上帝之手"

gogo8281

其實網球都唔少(除沙地球場)

herothree

i was gonna put tennis too
but and then i forget what's that person called...haha
sorri
i agree
tennis calling is very subjective as well