neverbe

Originally posted by 665 at 2007-4-4 11:48 PM:  Z- z' v) h, A3 F% J( |
第一集好亞視feel,不過個故事都幾通順,但最尾幾集全部三輯都係幾馬虎,不過第三輯真係好不知所謂,殭屍(1,2)中杜汶澤真係做得好好,所有人d感情線排得好好,好細緻,唔會似無線咁悶,不過第三輯,我睇左幾集之後真係好失望

) W1 G. A! M1 u" C
# Y5 d2 j  U, C0 V1 Z1 n, Q
老實講，到而家我仍然覺得, q% W5 y" [- j) a' A5 Q0 V8 c- t
" K6 b. ?2 e! q& c  |) C( S- ]
殭屍最失敗之處.......係由亞視黎拍，由陳十三導演="=
2 c$ M1 @, ?2 j0 U0 E3 V) D8 L; Y
前者無資源，後者勁老土，真係o徙左殭屍依個寫得唔錯ge劇本

neverbe

Originally posted by 阿感 at 2007-4-4 09:34 PM:" `( K4 I+ l0 K0 G$ n
我鐘意3,因為3玩得夠盡,夠膽o係電視劇做其他人唔敢做o既野(或者其他電視人諗都未諗過)

) R" ^) ^  Y& L$ X1 C; c
$ E1 I2 ~4 Q3 H; J
我反而覺得三玩得太盡wor= ="3 s' Z7 C4 y1 R0 e6 s1 z9 d" j! s' S

4 f7 M; X9 u0 i. v. L2 B而且仲睇得出個編劇玩到第三集己經無野好玩........
: q* t: b8 d* r4 l4 G
. O) T1 o; S5 m$ [7 g一黎完全無左我睇2個種新鮮感(仲新過1).......而且真係有d......怪6 g  Z: o; K- q$ S1 t
$ v' l' M2 _0 J+ P: T
佢的確好創新，但係創新得黎唔討好......7 i5 B% a( N( K7 s

( \: s4 n3 @5 N1 l, O1 U& \0 a' s/ \4 }1 r! t/ V

# J- d/ z: E7 ^+ n: c0 J% c' W1 U0 |我最唔鐘意就係點解要寫馬小虎係「地藏王」@@"1 }7 r5 ~( w4 c: k' e7 t

5 G; n0 A# n4 ]: `& T5 k佢條線本身個悲劇性好好，佢本身係一個著通人，仲要一個係好人，虛無ge都市人
6 l9 C) P  ~4 o) c+ ~8 m  k7 t# K8 \2 P
面對自己無能為力，但係又想幫手ge事情個種無力感真係好掂.....# z2 v) _6 w# x% w: O7 j
: N7 S2 V1 [6 h7 f0 S6 ]; L
點知睇左幾集，無鬼鬼端端變左地藏王@@"，個野真係想打去投訴(笑)

大優勢

第二部.......將臣角色揾華哥做非常好,好有形
* h, C' r3 u" f. L- U" y' X故事最合理,      其他角色做形都好好,,,,動作唔錯(人地係亞視呀)5 `. L  g- U9 @* x: i" F
  o+ z8 T" V* L# Q/ E: G
撞啱首歌good fit(唱K榜十七個星期冠軍)% x7 |9 g$ p2 z4 b* T
: h. e$ B2 ]0 x% Z& h

) q6 o, f$ t- G, n0 j第一....可能資源不足有啲求其  F# `+ z% L1 l7 A# }

+ z) `" }! m* e/ o第三......無明星又無- h% Y2 |2 S* F! i, i0 m
個劇本最攞命......話[命運]係最大敵人......簡直無聊都嘔

sheissobad

The first and second one

665

Originally posted by 大優勢 at 2007-4-5 01:13 PM:* H* B& J+ r: \- C9 b
第二部.......將臣角色揾華哥做非常好...

* T0 n( Z! {* y: o  r: \
第三輯首歌最難聽............................嘔心,d造型又唔係好得,衰過第一,二輯

665

之前一,二輯導演好似唔係陳十三,個故事大綱先係陳十三,但有一樣野好多人未必記得' U& a+ R& r+ m7 h9 |
"劉偉強"條仆街套第三輯加左好多自己既意見當正自己係監制,扮大導演同埋個d咁幼嫩既特技係佢搵ive個學生造(但條友係工作人員名單就唔放自己名),我係套第三輯拍緊個時己經知呢件事,不過諗唔到拍出黎會搞成咁,係殭屍三步曲最死得唔抵既一套

kantang4910

咁多人鍾意疆屍2而覺得彊3咁差,在我這個疆屍迷眼中剛剛相反' X; m5 Q5 \, r. w$ ~+ A0 p/ g% x! L
疆屍1係小弟十多年來會追看,甚至是會看的電視劇(另一套是十月初五的月光,其餘甚麽大長金,金枝玉葉我一集都未睇過)初看是它的創新,扭轉了疆屍的定義.追看是因為老套而劇情少泛搏.) `- w0 p: {& V5 F0 ~% E
到疆屍2時已失去新意而又要加點震撼力,等同一般電視劇--失敗% R5 k2 O  n) n- F$ O
疆屍3嘅天馬行空真的叫人拍案叫絕,起碼會造一些其它電視劇唔敢試的突破6 z) U) @2 r% y/ ?# I, o
比起那些白痴電視劇的公式--主角出場強絕震撼,突然低能受奸人所害,最後回復智慧收拾奸人$ |+ h  i4 d) j+ ~6 v
白痴兼無謂,仲要扮勁攪怖局,想我睇都難4 u, e1 Y' W, [% W  O' |2 [
期待疆屍4,希望再來超突破

sk

I "discovered" the series when it was in #3. I found the story was very creative and unlike most TV drama, the story was interesting from the beginning to the end. The king of mankind is willing to settle for being a school teacher and end his life as a typical man; Mixing the actors' reality and the story characters etc.$ {, G% z6 V! N  I" h

0 F0 Y, V' b3 M4 YAfter finishing #3, I watched the #2 on DVD. The story was very interest too and 任逹華 was very good in it. However, the ending was too much X-men and Matrix-like story telling. That was not creative.+ x' B$ f8 W7 M

6 f$ A" a; t) A7 T( Y- JOverall, I can't think of any TV show is as original and interesting as this series 1- 3. Too bad I don't think ATV is capable of making another one like this.

阿感

Originally posted by kantang4910 at  10:40 AM:
) C1 o7 a' k) h- R1 f! l" S$ ?  {  V5 B咁多人鍾意疆屍2而覺得彊3咁差,在我這...

) w# g$ c4 R8 O6 W# ^9 q# t+ V
) i$ U0 u' e0 G4 o5 L5 T
終於都有個同道中人,雖說第三集的故事與某些日木漫畫相似,但對於電視劇來講已有很大突破,已經唔係那些升級打大佬那種公式;而且故事結構都稱得上賞心悅目,睇到出係有心鋪排,入出了傳統電視劇的框框
! E7 _! Y5 l3 ^/ o) E
1 I0 Q" O  x# c4 S+ ?% O有版友提到劉偉強果條粉腸,佢係粉腸我非常認同,但亦無因此減低故事的可觀性) S% t$ v5 ~/ `) S2 ]9 R
% i0 t4 ~6 O1 h& B" u
[ Last edited by 阿感 on 2007-4-7 at 06:30 PM ]

我愛章小慧

Originally posted by kantang4910 at 2007-4-7 10:40 AM:2 f: D  u% t; l: P% e( `
咁多人鍾意疆屍2而覺得彊3咁差,在我這...

) e8 K0 u/ H* r- @我都覺得2係最差 , 我最鐘意既係1 ~~
' ]4 @% S; e( p* Z3 都好好 , 尤其佢夠疆將好多抽象體化
( n: ?) S" e: ?! u/ a但我覺得有時簡簡單單的 , 可能都好正~~" h; @; E9 _9 Y( b+ D' t
1 既山本一夫直情係令我著迷 , 佢果句對天佑講 :
  {- Z. _4 X$ u: ?& ^2 O* c"你永遠擺係兩難之處 , 以為就叫有情有義 ;
9 i: R" x2 l! f, R- Z, W我就唔同 , 我一直都目標明確~~". i: i2 w; R& l% b
我e+仲背得出 , 佢果種"反英雄"氣質真係超正
! y& C" ]9 A) i6 C8 G% a9 S而至2 , 我覺得真係 ... 煩過梵帝崗 , 亂過亂葬崗~~# G8 F" |. ~6 O. }  n/ f6 }4 m/ c' k6 }
唯一可取只有貞子一段~~