Chingy

Howard compare to Barthez.i would say Barthez is better.bt caroll...everytime i saw him come on,i just think man utd will lose or draw..i just cant give my faith to caroll..cech is good..i think Howard and Cech is about the same..and Arsenal new keeper Almunia,i think he got something.wt ppl think about him?

brightlee

Aluminia?
The worst GK in Premier League.

This is my comment
I got no idea why Arsene was not using S. Taylor.

No confident for Aluminia at all.
No real skills wor.......

He had so many chances.... Arsene gave him too many chances.
Except he played it well when they were vs Sheff Utd in FA cup, semil final replay,
He never did it well.....!!!!

Look at the sliding for Arsenal... that's one of the factors....
see how much difficulties for Toure, A. Cole and Lauren, you could find it out.

Shing

Originally posted by Michael Lo at 2005-3-22 01:35 AM:
卡路爾成日都話唔比機會佢
當佢有得出果時
無出色表現都算la
佢仲要整d搞笑野出黎
叫人點俾機會佢呀

我唔認同,記得在曼城時,last match vs liverpool
射極都過唔到十指關

brightlee

the problem for Roy Carroll is, he's too inconsistency (if you compare with Tim Howard)

He's not the "worst" GK in Premier League
but as you play in big club, this may cause you in troubles......

Shing

Originally posted by Michael Lo at 2005-3-22 01:41 AM:




係囉！係囉！
佢真係好鬼精
佢閃完再重投英超打曼城同維拉果時
已經無曼聯果時咁好

我唔認同,記得在曼城時,last match vs liverpool
射極都過唔到十指關

rider

You mean the goalkeeper of MU? If it's he, I'll suggest him to change his nationality. It's wasteful to remain in USA team!:cool:

Chingy

Almunia is not the worst keeper in the league..at least i think he is better than Lehamen.bt he dont play tht much for Arsenal and cant only blame on him when arsenal lost a goal..coz half is drfend fault.and sometime ppl had some wiked shot bt he cant save it.cant do anything.im not saying he is in the world class.bt i think he will be.of coz he did some mistakes b4.bt every keeper did mistakes.even Kahn,he did mistakes as well.bt the problem is he is world class,ppl will say unlucky or wtever to cover his mistakes.bt the keeper not in the world class like Almunia.coz he was not very good.so everytime when he did mistakes.ppl always say he is crap.bt the world class keeper did it.ppl never sed tht.

brightlee

Originally posted by Chingy at 2005-3-23 09:15:
Almunia is not the  ...

Guess what?
I will not try to agure with you.

But I just point out one simple thing
Defenders
If the GK plays well, normally, their defenders are playing well also. cos the defenders can have more confident to do their jobs ONLY.
If not, they need to use extra energy to try to cover the GK position.
IT's NOT ONLY talking ALMINUIA, I am talking about in general situation.

You can see so many backup GK in any league, even the team you are playing now,
You would lost confident when your backup GK playing badly, then it will cos you to lost your concentration on the fields....

you may believe it or not... but you can think about it......

shaqkobe

佢係一個有能力，但心理質素不穩定的龍門。如果可以打返D信心返黎就好勁。