151515 發表於 2006-1-30 09:42 PM
**** 作者被禁止或刪除 內容自動屏蔽 ****
機密 發表於 2006-1-30 09:44 PM
[quote]Originally posted by [i]151515[/i] at 2006-1-30 21:42:
5n c-]"D
Op
3V[HAjV[+Eip
but 鄧艾and陸遜have 10 pts,姜維only9 [/quote]
UR
wRC(bj
G6zSr-T-G
But I don't think鄧艾and陸遜 is really better than 姜維. Even they are clever, 姜維 was taught by 諸葛亮. He learnt ~90% from 諸葛亮.
dfn!N'kIO
k3w H5P_
[[i] Last edited by 機密 on 2006-1-30 at 09:45 PM [/i]]
151515 發表於 2006-1-30 09:45 PM
**** 作者被禁止或刪除 內容自動屏蔽 ****
機密 發表於 2006-1-30 09:46 PM
[quote]Originally posted by [i]151515[/i] at 2006-1-30 21:45:
oZ"U,a;j
!?R2N3fx ^XBL)R)h/Q'g
cc^#?xkmmA&c3_W
why?
6\N(I-}e(P
b,lT2~.WH
其實他們實力差不多,很難比較:o [/quote]
Q'cv
F"g)|Y
$R l4O/vx6o+JjJ$S}
see #22 Thus
c0VJZ7u/`B$\
u4m kOJ[8^1jz,Ys9W
智慧: 諸葛亮-->司馬懿--->陸遜--->姜維--->鄧艾--->
*tGiT9[ E0SU
T2RO/i%l+O[t2w
軍事才能:諸葛亮-->司馬懿--->陸遜~鄧艾~姜維
&cT;]?3}w:Fe
3hy
Wy0nz
政治才能:<--- actually I forgot the details.
r$J!ZV M*q5eY M
6wc T7Hn;x
打:姜維--->鄧艾--->司馬懿--->陸遜--->諸葛亮
機密 發表於 2006-1-30 09:50 PM
In addition, a merit for 姜維 you haven't consider for him. 姜維's fascination is better than the others because he was the only student of 諸葛亮.
*A\9wOl8H9]
M8I#F$P
w}4YJ`
[[i] Last edited by 機密 on 2006-1-30 at 09:56 PM [/i]]
151515 發表於 2006-1-30 09:51 PM
**** 作者被禁止或刪除 內容自動屏蔽 ****
機密 發表於 2006-1-30 09:55 PM
[quote]Originally posted by [i]151515[/i] at 2006-1-30 21:51:
hj6v;s)@?c'b*XWJT
`2WoJ(Y:b#J,W5z"M
k-UJ!ylXo
他比孔明更偉大 [/quote]
|IN:SVxh'ly%x4|
9C4d/`m)[9U
Agree. Both of them were extremely loyalty. However, he was more great because he was in more poor situation. He could maintain a same loyality to his boss.
151515 發表於 2006-1-30 09:58 PM
**** 作者被禁止或刪除 內容自動屏蔽 ****
機密 發表於 2006-1-30 10:03 PM
[quote]Originally posted by [i]151515[/i] at 2006-1-30 21:58:
j8|b2Q&T9M r:^c
)b!k;T;o,pN;y p
#|!P{&Y7\Pf
他支撐了蜀國三十年,雖然孔明也有27年(207-234),但那時的人材比姜維時期的好很多,五虎已屈機 [/quote]
;v.i2{SGAi6S}J
yes, that's the point.:)
151515 發表於 2006-1-30 10:20 PM
**** 作者被禁止或刪除 內容自動屏蔽 ****
機密 發表於 2006-1-30 10:29 PM
[quote]Originally posted by [i]151515[/i] at 2006-1-30 22:20:
[?%bjQ/~]/?L&V:K
)O5Z/A&zoQSe:V
:[&^R6M/aL{
\
陸遜也偉大,但不得善終...... [/quote]
x%j
_L?0wT-cq
Many '3 countries' peoples 不得善終 too:D
151515 發表於 2006-1-30 10:32 PM
**** 作者被禁止或刪除 內容自動屏蔽 ****
CHECSS 發表於 2006-1-31 12:21 AM
[quote]Originally posted by [i]151515[/i] at 2006/1/30 21:32:
8D[0| PHO V9ca
4djo#Bl
E"e\A
V8y"Xg_{;L1F4`
but i think智慧: 諸葛亮-->司... [/quote]
P)b&a ~Z/`F2cC
why you think司馬懿 and 陸遜 are good at fight than 諸葛亮 ?????????????
nashisthebestpg 發表於 2006-1-31 01:07 AM
聽聞真正的history上,諸葛亮的軍事能力未如三國演義般吹得咁勁.........
N"Yb;f+G)H
佢勁係勁在治國能力............
~!f/}:q0e&ho
-iov3|u*aM
QN
係咪如此?
benny0105 發表於 2006-1-31 01:46 AM
[quote]Originally posted by [i]nashisthebestpg[/i] at 2006-1-31 01:07 AM:
%Vqt*ezm+Z
聽聞真正的history上,諸葛亮的軍事能力未如三國演義般吹得咁勁.........
"nC F`W(?
佢勁係勁在治國能力............
R'h;M?J-gk
I.A)A+I |z
係咪如此? [/quote]
!{HaU4l]*RZ Rgz
zVI k%r3t3fBz
$vk%f@D?h-HO
f:NP[C9U oz U
其實又有幾多人真係睇過三國志丫...
K4v(\N["Z/@m(W,BY%l
好多人只不過睇完神化既「三國演義」就信以為真
nashisthebestpg 發表於 2006-1-31 01:58 AM
[quote]Originally posted by [i]benny0105[/i] at 2006-1-31 01:46 AM:
F+lYDd%_5N6q Z#q\
rb+g4^OQ%t!n J
WX3ii
fo A
Eg/g|Q
n?x
CwdXx8]
其實又有幾多人真係睇過三國志丫...
M ] j};fWu b7P
好多人只不過睇完神化既「三國演義」就信以為真 [/quote]
8m7{3iV-W)Ozb;T
我嗰次係三聯見到本三國志,入面係逐個人物講,
pU:X-oo8?)\
唔係好似三國演義好似故事咁講出黎........
3@,mUZS9R
:Ubzqd
三國志真係咁ga? 咁咪無咁好睇........
nashisthebestpg 發表於 2006-1-31 02:01 AM
呢個網係講有關三國正史~
8y0b"B,BlG.t-@
不過我諗好多人都有睇過~
ZZ a3l+w
[url]http://k-fung.net/han/real.htm[/url]
奇 發表於 2006-1-31 02:05 AM
[quote]Originally posted by [i]nashisthebestpg[/i] at 2006-1-31 01:07 AM:
:csYmj,`'N
聽聞真正的history上,諸葛亮的軍事能力未如三國演義般吹得咁勁.........
F+z*F{z3wL
佢勁係勁在治國能力............
1@?!_ez/v1ybX'F+n
"N%K%Gcx b^ J
係咪如此? [/quote]
;B9{
t1I gz*k,|
歷史中諸葛亮的軍事能力的確沒演義中那麼屈機,但也算不俗,始終對司馬懿也
4K5e1B+tX$A
沒有佔下風:)
奇 發表於 2006-1-31 02:09 AM
[quote]Originally posted by [i]nashisthebestpg[/i] at 2006-1-31 02:01 AM:
4~Bq ]~G(bs0l G
呢個網係講有關三國正史~
9o&k6r0b9IyuVk*g%v
不過我諗好多人都有睇過~
5Y sCh3gF
[url]http://k-fung.net/han/real.htm[/url] [/quote]
0@+P? t,K
正史中張松只有110cm?:o
$t!i4VHJ1|
侏儒?
step025 發表於 2006-1-31 07:13 AM
你睇演義定火鳳? 你又點知佢地打得?
,Ta%Jz
A
z2J&c8|X3K1l.g
阿壽寫打鬥一向草草了事, 姜維鄧艾無一次唔係不相佰仲, 點分邊個勁?
KB'm'lu'P7K:Hz
}'q8g9@~sPQbu??
諸葛亮係上述當中絕對唔係最好嘅軍事家, 用人亦只用文人如楊儀, 馬謖等紙上談兵之輩, 可來成功?
(J,X%wt'u
zM b&k\
C2D
4Oe&y8m9wW3v
相反司馬懿係對負孟達充份表現出打仗最重要的機動性, 諸葛亮即使有再多人力物力也不能做到, 以他謹慎的做人態度
Fe}lJv,F*[
-[
bz#zvq9|h V&Z\[
有人話諸葛亮最勁, 因為佢死在, 蜀就完全唔掂
&?:e,Rw9Pk\-f
聽完更加覺得諸葛亮唔掂, 死前唔陪養多D有用嘅人用(有一大堆文人嘅), 有魏延如此勇猛的人又唔重用......可憐自己個仔一野就比鄧艾打爆......
"WE8[-\N1TX ~
司馬懿兩個仔都至高無上, 個孫司馬炎仲統一埋......
.\TF*vt*kHH
陸遜個仔都係大都督,同羊祜更惺惺相惜......
_C(c3vX3`
諸葛亮!!!你做的事顯出你特別, 更加, 無敵偉大啊!!!
$Vu9R1a"Da"P!~
6q.JBuR!t&I+`
講番姜維鄧艾, 他倆各方面都不分上下(兩人亦往往是同僚針對的人), 但在政革方面, 鄧艾全勝, 他的團田制帶來足夠糧草以應付任何對戰, 相反姜維在政治方面差不多是沒有的
#ui)eYW%Ns*^5xb
[mFJk'T9C9Wz
我講完依堆野之後, 想講嘅係諸葛亮死後最厲害既人物係 ------- [b]李世民[/b]:P