娛樂滿紛 26FUN » 吹水版 » 陳易希會考12分,應唔應該俾佢入U?

155220 發表於 2006-8-22 10:03 AM

俾佢讀都未必有用，因為佢可能無能力去完成大學課程:haha:

pangpang2066 發表於 2006-8-22 10:40 AM

其實都預左佢成績唔會好. 如果係你, 有大學一早收左你, 你都會放懶啦.j.A6|N } ]
%V&}+\1S| q
根據本人於該校任教的朋友所講, 佢返學就等於人地返大學做research, 佢係唔駛上0個d正規既堂, 全職去研究, 仲有lab既人做助手. 另外, 由於佢本身英文好差, 佢出d論文都係搵老師做鎗手, 唔係佢自己做.p/e5Ph\$T

ih/D8?2h;T9B 所以可以話係佢全部香港人出錢請d老師同lab助理去谷出黎既新星.

skjeiw 發表於 2006-8-22 01:14 PM

[quote]Originally posted by [i]阿感[/i] at 2006-8-22 12:26 AM:(t7s2lP)Nm/j*T:k
M4f&jOY2o#{.J
會考更加唔代表d乜野,有d才能唔係人人有,雖然我唔知 陳易希真正o既才能去到邊,不個大學收得佢唔會話冇原因o既 [/quote]
1F!aaC4ke}/x$]C }U2|Z%]|!I$Y,?#b5n
咁個個都係讀到書先有得讀大學架啦:m;eq+o2E T O4i_
佢連入中六14分都無...我理得佢其他邊樣勁

skjeiw 發表於 2006-8-22 01:15 PM

[quote]Originally posted by [i]pangpang2066[/i] at 2006-8-22 10:40 AM:{llm&K"mZV
其實都預左佢成績唔會好. 如果係你, ... [/quote]
HHwOi`B0v 都唔係中英文唔合格掛

bigfish 發表於 2006-8-22 01:17 PM

我想問佢做乜咁出名o既?
STU.Op7^V 發明左d 咩呀?

skjeiw 發表於 2006-8-22 01:22 PM

[quote]Originally posted by [i]bigfish[/i] at 2006-8-22 01:17 PM:8GI&^ v0_Hr%x
我想問佢做乜咁出名o既?
f8P DTujK/K ^i 發明左d 咩呀? [/quote]
]F W+C$E0cG;}_ 唔知發明左d乜,跟住仲有粒星用佢個名黎命名,仲比科大收左f.5之後就入大學

ronald001120 發表於 2006-8-22 02:41 PM

入到u佢知味道

sexysexy 發表於 2006-8-22 03:11 PM

佢咁細個發明咗智能機械人, 你地又識唔識呀, 會考囉30分又會唔會砌得出呀, 佢既學術咪係physic 囉, 佢連大學要學既電路設計, logic gate, 寫入rom 既programming language 都已經識喇, 只係差在語文方面者, 並唔係有粒星就入得u, 你估科大傻架)F6w1La*gs0C^
*{8`'Eds+g1\!@S
都唔明點解要話人地會考差, 就唔應該入u, 你地呢啲咪自己睇少自己囉, 仲有如果俾你地choose, 你會為咗考oral 而放棄去加州大學做research 既機會嗎, 大家知少少就係到......, 真係笑死人喇 :D

queenly 發表於 2006-8-22 06:27 PM

香港既考試根本無法反映一個學生真正既能力, 香港考試制度極度迂腐, 難度考試考得差就可以話一個學生是無能嗎？

shingshing1234 發表於 2006-8-22 07:10 PM

可能小第見識少...
%Q8}!l5SW | 我就唔覺得給佢入 low....講真..會考30分or above no al .這個方法都算可行...但係給一個12分既中5生...一次過 jump左2年..直接去到大學....我覺得全香港又唔係得佢一個會咁既發明啊.觀星啊之類,,..點解科大會咁有信心去給佢入呢..而且個校長講...大學d course係給 d 思想成熟既人讀.....他應該想想自己係唔係夠咁既 能力去應付大學既野...個人認為..應該在下面努力多一下...咁樣對自己都有幫助~人生練歷都多d 啊~咁樣上大學..我怕只係...給他更多既挫折...難切係好事 low

bigfish 發表於 2006-8-23 02:10 AM

[quote]Originally posted by [i]sexysexy[/i] at 2006-8-22 03:11 PM:
E ?F eq#|:v[(kL{ 佢咁細個發明咗智能機械人, 你地又識... [/quote]
,ej;|0P0j%D!a 咩係智能機械人? 希望個 product match 返個 product name 啦 :D

samuria 發表於 2006-8-23 02:03 PM

[quote]Originally posted by [i]queenly[/i] at 2006-8-22 06:27 PM:xE_P{8QfvO
香港既考試根本無法反映一個學生真正既能力, 香港考試制度極度迂腐, 難度考試考得差就可以話一個學生是無能嗎？ [/quote]
K*F'a b;Z[t c+uE 6Xh8ZQUn
Of course no exam system can prove one's ability in full picture
5hZ'me*ULG But now, he has [color=Red][size=5]no proven [/size][/color]for his ability for entering university2y6UtF"L-F*S#zi
Language subjects are all failed :nogood:(E!p$MU%mn
How come he can communicate in depth with others in English?

YingTung 發表於 2006-8-23 06:38 PM

[quote]Originally posted by [i]sexysexy[/i] at 2006-8-22 03:11 PM:P;FY'[3|{dF3j
佢咁細個發明咗智能機械人, 你地又識... [/quote]K
r2v6X {ZOu$Kt|
0A)r;X-^V$r/@1r/F
其實好多人唔鐘意佢既原因係佢好鬼串,扮哂天才。]&s:xw^A v
唔知你有無睇佢本新書,佢入面張張相都真係好扮野,
9T8d TU0xUO~:A-eD o的序仲要話到自己係明星。
/fCqJ ? 書既內容仲不知所謂,左抄右抄,o的小實驗全部o係其他書搵到哂。
6T6~"LM#ie+pp
Zs@%xC'dT 無可否認,佢的確對科學有一定認識,但最憎佢一樣野係佢自以為是。
)y!t ?iXs"a 會考衰左如果佢自己認錯,認唔夠努力,我地會原諒同明白。
qx*`T h0r/d7p0Q 但佢竟然白痴到搵籍口話掛住研究,好似錯不在他咁......。K2A E{[$sU)g
呢類人真係唔值得人幫住佢。

YingTung 發表於 2006-8-23 06:40 PM

再者,科大似係做下show俾人睇,.}jd#bN] vv
證明自己比其他大學更能做到求學不是求分數。W4d&gW7r:X u
對於陳易希...似係呢場show既棋子。

pigcat 發表於 2006-8-23 10:26 PM

其實我覺得好多人都眼紅佢...
:ElUb7i[
i(~1@ b F,z 如果真係好似某d人話就咁觀下星就入到uHu(k GlI:G
咁佢咪去試下做第2個陳易希lor0^O'c2H5s1z$\F/Dh
h9a%tX)|bGpE2Cn
科大咁做得就有佢ge原因
D[}LvQ)l 就連科大自己都主動邀請..U't"l OL$Vgs
其他人又眼紅黎做咩呢??
%h/L2Lt[(l
b9k#tIc Wc 可能呢位陳小朋友真係有才華 |'V+RLK
而既然有u賞識佢 O,lU6k:Fj"{y0t
點解唔可能直升上去jei??AD!trHx`

Wr7i#G(e d人成日批評香港教育制度死板...咩只係識學生死讀書9w wp@} ]%w)T6R+g
又批評會考一戰定生死等等

UIw3xD!Mx5CJu 咁而家有個人可以唔同於正常傳統途徑入uX,O[V5@*GS+v$^s
但係又有人唔知出於咩心態去反對
)Mn+M+m
A 呢個真係好矛盾..:confused:

loklok117 發表於 2006-8-23 11:23 PM

我支持:good:
J j:f$yF l'}:FGg 我都有考過會考'n NF|1G?
8科8A,A-LEVLE4A,5A我都見過[9P"]}6?&s'Rd
讀得書叻唔代表成就一定高:fight:
*fhBO(|W(z 最重要對社會在貢獻YJ5`:r7R-Q!z
~6Qn+e JPL
老套講個例子
o
R WAgr,ri0jH 李嘉誠有邊個唔識;h3ODQ-fza
佢既成就有目共睹)r5j3v.U4{a5KW
佢讀好多書咩?:confused:
Cx u4^8w4Cy+Y 發達前有好多大學學位?:confused:+}7m;s1{V4~
!Afev&_:G,VWd:`WR
反觀而家好多大學生畢業後$WeN.U7H*N
讀完一個學位再讀一個學位
+e3\`&R+f 重唔知自己有咩想做,有咩目標l+~~t&G xS

3YE!B\,_P{_
\J 可能今年有份會考既考生
NYI$C%F4i7QA 覺得好唔公平C wd0v{M~{
但問自己一句你有咩理想?!Vs4jP5oV8x&[
:confused:畢業後有咩目標計劃?:confused:0T;s
\1H:]-eA*Ju
升到中六,大學會唔會有佢一樣既成就貢獻

stockman 發表於 2006-8-24 03:40 AM

To my surprise most people don't think 陳 易 希 deserves to go to U with only 12 points from the HKCEE.  I don't know how many of them are out of jealousy and how many of them truly worry about how he can handle life in U.v5i @D+O

%x_(sL(W"} I wondered how many of those who objected are currently in U or have already graduated from U?  An A student in high school may help him do well in U, but an A student in U doesn't always lead to a good future when he enters the real business world.  Of course it all depends on what you studies.  You definitely need to be a good student studying Medicine or Laws to become a good doctor or lawyer.  But how about Business majors?  How about Political Science?  An A student in Marketing makes this U grad a good sales person?
h;js n})A1]-|#r O2q)Rw1^|,H{G
The HK government tries so hard to convince its people that learning is not about tests and scores, but the truth is scores very much determine everything.  From what I read 陳易希 has learned and achieved so much outside of the classroom and those not covered in the syllabus and exams.  This is reported in Aug 22's 蘋果日報:@/V3XuIlvA$?

NdDV]i"L A&g '陳 易 希 在 暑 假 遠 赴 美 國 加 州 理 工 學 院 參 與 火 星 研 究 期 間 ， 在 大 學 宿 舍 認 識 了 一 名 巴 基 斯 坦 裔 同 房 ， 後 來 得 悉 他 妹 妹 曾 遇 上 交 通 意 外 而 終 身 癱 瘓 ， 只 有 一 隻 手 指 可 以 活 動 ； 陳 易 希 遂 與 學 院 的 同 學 合 力 發 明 單 指 操 作 的 電 腦 輸 入 裝 置 ， 讓 她 可 藉 此 與 外 界 聯 繫 。 陳 易 希 昨 日 說 ， 同 房 的 妹 妹 現 已 開 始 使 用 該 裝 置 ， 操 作 順 利 。 他 計 劃 把 裝 置 運 來 香 港 展 出 。'
wC5p0PC$g ;i%?&JN1v| `m_
Now do you think this is a greater achievement or having 9 or 10 As for HKCEE?  Which one has a bigger impact to the society?  If going to U helps prepare a person for the future and contribute to the society, do you think what he did during the this summer is a great contribution?  How many U grad or even PhD can do what he did?"j6P-h+sHctP;zh
y6znqq*Jz!_
What I try to say is by typical standard, meaning based strictly on test results many more people are more deserving than 陳 易 希 to go to U.  But he's not a typical student and he has already achieved a lot in his young life.  He deserves special treatment and should be admitted to U.  In any society, special people always get special treatment -- so no need to complain 'it's not fair'.  They may be smarter or work harder and they earn the right to be treated differently.  When many students use their spare time on Karaoke, movies, playing sports, YouTube, MySpace, or even 26FUN, 陳 易 希 probably spent his time on his next invention and missed all that fun.  Is it fair? EYS,U-{+Gc&|| B
'v#Ns;In1J+F/_
From what I read I believe he'll move to U.S. to further his study in a few years.  The HK government should feel sorry to see him leave, but I think under the current environment in HK 陳 易 希 won't maximize his potential.  Hopefully he will return to HK after he finishes study in the U.S.

cgdmzlam 發表於 2006-8-24 04:48 PM

我覺得佢未必可以應付大學既課程NA)n8H;l?
佢除左有小小小聰明W q6g{%xMa
?
我覺得佢邊度勁~!~~~~~~
4B~~j9D d1Z%Gr 我覺得比果d10優既狀元直升大學都好過叫佢升大學讀~~~

\C3g,RV-W$r 唉~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~"rM0J)h/a%~3{9p
#fB'A|u$fg
                 無咁大個頭  就唔好帶咁大頂帽啦~~~~~~~~

skjeiw 發表於 2006-8-24 07:29 PM

[quote]Originally posted by [i]cgdmzlam[/i] at 2006-8-24 04:48 PM:9uh1_C2ek8H+E5~J$Y
我覺得佢未必可以應付大學既課程
xF{m&OLf1P+R#r 佢... [/quote]
)H3k+Zk7|G&gG 科大笠落佢個頭je

zxc3201163 發表於 2006-8-24 11:15 PM

[quote]Originally posted by [i]pigcat[/i] at 2006-8-23 10:26 PM:
(U5RD z5a;F(\ 其實我覺得好多人都眼紅佢...0TN)d7gc

F0t8z"E[Y m4` 如果... [/quote]5Gp.`(p!I-v0ZeB s9{
)U4_1o"`'X4?T*eR1wD4?

)g5}td W3T8x&E 如果我知觀星都會入到u ge
gb!] ekBA#@ 我一早就做左la~~~$N:YASm0lX
佢連英文口試都唔去考呀;hUZ2K6`_ HPS
咁ge學習態度都可以比佢入u
:Y9c#E Tg#ngr(i 我真係好無言:mad::mad::mad:

查看完整版本: 陳易希會考12分,應唔應該俾佢入U?