[quote]Originally posted by [i]Gretzky[/i] at 2005-7-7 12:25 PM:
Read the comments above...let's be ... [/quote]
i strongly agree. but this won't prevent other members from posting such information. indeed, members had been posting inaccurate information long before the establishment of 【飲食天地】, and had been rewarded with points.
[quote]Originally posted by [i]Gretzky[/i] at 2005-7-7 08:25 AM:
Read the comments above...let's be ... [/quote]
I agree With Gretzky....
Recipe is Ok, 健康飲食資訊 and 食療 need professional verification that beyone what we could provide. I suggest we delete all post realted to these subjects.
[quote]Originally posted by [i]Gretzky[/i] at 2005-02-01 19:25:
Read the comments above...let's be ... [/quote]
agree with gretzky's idea,,,
ditching the thead is the best way for all 26fun members to be safe...
I am always so unlucky, a week after i became a co host,.. this happens..
[quote]Originally posted by [i]singgeihot[/i] at 2005-02-01 19:29:
i strongly agree. but this won'... [/quote]
maybe we could ask moderators to subtract points to members who doesn't have doctor/nutrients approved that those are correct information
[quote]Originally posted by [i]singgeihot[/i] at 2005-7-7 08:04 AM:
tenten & fatfat, what are your ...
1) We can suggest the moderators not to give point(s) to members who are posting 健康飲食資訊 without a verifiable source. If they agree, then this rule will be stated clearly in 【飲食天地】. We can also suggest members to consult their doctors or registered nutritionist before they practice anything that is being posted here.
2) Remove 健康飲食資訊 as one of 【飲食天地】's 加分題. We'll focus on cooking tips, recipes, and restaurant guides only.
[/quote]
my opinions:
1. Agree to state [color=Blue]"members to consult their doctors or registered nutritionist before they practice anything that is being posted here."[/color]
It should be the right and postive attitude to somethings related to health no matter where the information sourcing.
2. [color=Brown]We can suggest the moderators not to give point(s) to members who are posting 健康飲食資訊 without a verifiable source.[/color]. This is a paradox. It can help to improve the information (資訊) quality, but it also discourage members enthusiasm on giviing their ideas/opinions.
Honestly speaking, some of the information sources may be like "阿媽 say" or "婦女新知 say". If we set this retriction, it may be something lose the objective of "吹水區" on 吹水. [color=Blue]My suggestion is let members have a field to write, but not retricted. he can write down "XX report", "阿媽 say", or "婦女新知 say" and this field needed to be highlighted in color[/color]
3. [color=Brown]Remove 健康飲食資訊 as one of 【飲食天地】's 加分題.[/color]. Agree to remove from formal 加分題, or just give a fixed points (say 1 mark for "轉貼" or 2-3 marks for "自己經驗", of course experience needs to be reasonable and practical). It is because I believe most of the 健康飲食資訊 is from "轉貼".
4. We'll focus on cooking tips, recipes, and restaurant guides only. Not totally agree (tend to be neutral and near disagree), as 健康飲食資訊 is a key part of 飲食文化.
Maybe, we can change 健康飲食資訊 to 健康飲食討論.
hoping that the above can help.
[quote]Originally posted by [i]tenmadio[/i] at 2005-7-7 12:32 PM:
maybe we could ask moderators to subtract points to members who doesn't have doctor/nutrients approved that those are correct information [/quote]
well, at least not add points to the ones that continue to post.
[quote]Originally posted by [i]singgeihot[/i] at 2005-02-01 19:34:
well, at least not add points to the ones that continue to post. [/quote]
not adding points may not stop them to post inaccurate information though...
[quote]Originally posted by [i]tenmadio[/i] at 2005-7-7 12:36 PM:
not adding points may not stop them to post inaccurate information though... [/quote]
see my opinion in #29.... we can't stop them.... but we shouldn't encourage them.
[quote]Originally posted by [i]fatfatdragon[/i] at 2005-02-01 19:33:
my opinions:
1. Agree to state... [/quote]
or maybe we could change
健康飲食資訊 or 健康飲食討論 to 健康飲食奇文
which means legend,, may not be true, so people will know that too
[quote]Originally posted by [i]tenmadio[/i] at 2005-02-01 19:39:
or maybe we could change
健康飲食資訊 or 健康飲食討論 to 健康飲食奇文
which means legend,, may not be true, so people will know that too [/quote]
so, we all agree to ditch that thread now???
[quote]Originally posted by [i]fatfatdragon[/i] at 2005-7-7 12:33 PM:
my opinions:
1. Agree to state... [/quote]
thank you fat fat for your input. after reading everyone's comments, i've decided to remove all 健康飲食資訊 links from 【飲食天地】.... and we'll go from there.
[quote]Originally posted by [i]singgeihot[/i] at 2005-02-01 19:41:
thank you fat fat for your input. after reading everyone's comments, i've decided to remove all 健康飲食資訊 links from 【飲食天地】.... and we'll go from there. [/quote]
ok :D
dats good
[quote]Originally posted by [i]tenmadio[/i] at 2005-7-7 12:41 PM:
so, we all agree to ditch that thread now??? [/quote]
yes, less work, fewer confusions, fewer problems, easier to manage :)
members could still post inaccurate information as they wish, but that's out of our control.
put all the wrong information in a thread call 健康飲食精神病院
Then we can discoruage posting more :)
[quote]Originally posted by [i]tenmadio[/i] at 2005-7-7 08:41 AM:
so, we all agree to ditch that thread now??? [/quote]
my opinions are from the view point of a bbs user only, if choice, i will honor to people have more experience in this area. I agree to delete.
[quote]Originally posted by [i]singgeihot[/i] at 2005-7-7 08:41 AM:
thank you fat fat for your input. after reading everyone's comments, i've decided to remove all 健康飲食資訊 links from 【飲食天地】.... and we'll go from there. [/quote]
totally agree :)
[[i] Last edited by fatfatdragon on 2005-7-7 at 08:56 AM [/i]]
[quote]Originally posted by [i]johnwu[/i] at 2005-7-7 12:49 PM:
put all the wrong information in a thread call 健康飲食精神病院
Then we can discoruage posting more :) [/quote]
Could you be the 院長? :lol::lol::lol:
[quote]Originally posted by [i]singgeihot[/i] at 2005-7-7 08:58 AM:
Could you be the 院長? :lol::lol::lol: [/quote]
support :D:D:lol::lol:
[quote]Originally posted by [i]fatfatdragon[/i] at 2005-7-7 12:53 PM:
my opinions are from the view point of a bbs user only, if choice, i will honor to people have more experience in this area. I agree to delete. [/quote]
fatfat, thank you for your understanding. we're all trying to do something good.... but in the mean time, we wouldn't want a good thing to lead to a disaster.
thank you very much for your participation and support, we truly appreciate them :D
[quote]Originally posted by [i]singgeihot[/i] at 2005-7-7 08:58 AM:
Could you be the 院長? :lol::lol::lol: [/quote]
:lol::lol::lol::lol:
why not :) but I don't think I can cure them, I can only lock them up for life
:lol::lol::lol::lol::lol::lol: