harvey22

i think rooney won't get ban if the dutch fa dun report it to eng fa, so is up to the dutch fa, but even so he can appeal right?

[ Last edited by harvey22 on 2006-8-5 at 04:55 PM ]

brightlee

Originally posted by harvey22 at 2006-8-5 18:48:
i think rooney won't get ban if the dutch fa dun report it to enf fa, so is up to the dutch fa, but even so he can appeal right?

yes

harvey22

http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=ZVcnBY0j8xs
check out the replay, dis cuss.

Thanks for your video so we can filter-004 about this incident
+4

[ Last edited by brightlee on 2006-8-5 at 06:59 PM ]

brightlee

Originally posted by harvey22 at 2006-8-5 18:54:
http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=ZVcnBY0j8xs
check out the replay, dis cuss.

I watched the replay

Yes, definity red card!

No doubt about it.

harvey22

Originally posted by brightlee at 2006-8-5 04:56 PM:


I watched the replay

Yes, definity red card!

No doubt about it.

no way!!!! tell me why?

brightlee

Originally posted by harvey22 at 2006-8-5 18:57:


no way!!!! tell me why?

look at his ARM!

also I heard that the referee was really straight in that match

If he's keeping that straight, I am not surprised he would send his off in this case.

That's between a "deep" Yellow and a straight red

I would choose red if I am straight

also, remember the position of the referee, he was just standing 3 yards of this incident


i.e. he's clear what he was doing.

brightlee

p.s. I am not bias in any side......

harvey22

I wanna raise a few questions:

1) Is a friendly, is it a bit harsh to dish out a straight red for this incident?
2) Is rooneys arm intentional? coz i think the ref thinks it is, thats why red.
3) The players reaction leading to rooneys red?? coz he was clearly acting, look at the replay, right after rooney got a red he got straight back up!

harvey22

thx for the points dude lol~ i guess i finally reply something with quality lol~

brightlee

1) even if that's friendly, that's no different as the standard of individual referee, sometimes you may see some referees that he may "invite" some coaches to sweep one player who had a terrible incident. THIS IS NOT HIS JOB, this is his sympathy inside his heart. That's NOT GRANTED!
2) Yes, I think his left arm was intention
3) The red card was not due to the acting from the defender, it's depended from the action of Wayne Rooney

Harvey, thanks for your points, I am appreciated about your work in these posts.