Board logo

標題: 您覺得中藥是否好過西藥? [積極回應者+] [打印本頁]

作者: nirvana_169    時間: 2005-5-31 09:15 PM     標題: 您覺得中藥是否好過西藥? [積極回應者+]

Do you think Chinese medicine is better than Western?+ I" h0 i; G* e7 v" V7 J8 k

; u# {# |7 V4 D: e! Y! e& Y2 x' z/ `it is beacuse Chinese medicine normally is balancing the human body to achieve recover rather like Western to tackle / breakdown the virus to health0 r4 D5 Y; Q' T2 o) B
0 T: o: O% ]7 B. q( d
[ Last edited by 樂壇渣Fit人 on 2005-6-3 at 12:18 PM ]
作者: naz124    時間: 2005-5-31 10:27 PM

Hard to compare la.  Chinese medicine is more preventive while western medicine is only useful if something is wrong.
作者: vivienna    時間: 2005-5-31 10:53 PM

Originally posted by nirvana_169 at 2005-5-31 09:15 PM:  u' D' g$ y: S
Do you think Chinese medicine is be...
# _! Q+ W  H8 V6 B+ `
that's a question with a very very long answer.
9 o* L; Q& l* g% L" r
1 E# Z; ]! j1 I2 Ibut there is nothing better or worse as such.
作者: Gretzky    時間: 2005-6-1 12:26 AM

Some physical ailments need operative procedure, and unfortunately Chinese medicine can't do it. Even patients in the Mainland uses surgeries to get well.
( G! A" b  q0 Z7 ?' v/ m- k+ ]: L& V/ v  T- y5 Y
But for minor sickness and preventive medicine, Chinese Medicine has its own worth.% n4 R+ p0 I* @- F( E9 M- q
3 s( l4 a9 r, \
Your question is a bit too general, if you need a specific instruction I would suggest seeing a doctor (Chinese or Western) la.
4 {# B+ W, j. b) `% q) l6 q
9 ], H3 r- ^# z) m. g' \$ s2 K
作者: Jho808    時間: 2005-6-1 02:36 AM

i can't tell which one is better ....but there is one thing i think it is very amazing from the chinese Dr....becoz they can just touching your hand that they can know what is going on in your body.......that is very cool......but i believe in chinese more than western....
作者: 樂壇渣Fit人    時間: 2005-6-3 12:19 PM

呢個topic睇下有無其他會員答) W( y" m% \& v& r. w7 Y4 z
無既話我先答您
作者: 良友    時間: 2005-6-3 12:21 PM

我會睇下咩病先,唔同病我會揀唔同醫生
作者: karate_pau    時間: 2005-6-3 12:24 PM

急病,發燒西藥會好d
作者: karate_pau    時間: 2005-6-3 12:25 PM

但係咳,感冒,好耐唔清就中醫好好多
作者: thatsok    時間: 2005-6-3 04:18 PM

邊樣好d都係睇情況。3 q: U6 K% k1 }* i5 y3 l3 n  l# m( l

* E1 D  w9 \+ }9 U我覺得西藥重速效,有d病食西藥好快d,
3 ~( J' D, H% ~; d0 j但係食西藥可能有副作用,飲咳水食感冒藥都可能覺得眼訓。
& U' \, g1 W% h  Q2 g
# `4 S5 F1 f1 x0 z- y1 V4 ^6 I中藥包括醫病,治標治本,平時服用都可以調養身體。
( m: J1 X9 l5 y) k  H* [1 E' r  R西藥好似只係針對醫病,保健方面西醫平時就叫人有均衡飲食、做多d運動、注意生活規律。。。
作者: sk    時間: 2005-6-4 12:01 PM

Does anyone know if 中藥 is scientifically proven?
作者: singgeihot    時間: 2005-6-4 12:17 PM

Originally posted by sk at 2005-6-4 12:01 PM:
! C# T1 R$ _0 T. a7 nDoes anyone know if 中藥 is scientifically proven?
0 i- w/ ?7 ?' y) O, V. \1 ^' ~" B- o) P- v% Q
Chinese medicine had been empirical all along. But scientific work has been going on around the world. I personally know a professor in Canada who is planning to work on 冬蟲草
作者: sfxc0000    時間: 2005-6-4 01:25 PM

Originally posted by thatsok at 2005-6-3 04:18 PM:6 R+ k& ?- U8 B; f
邊樣好d都係睇情況。
' }4 [: X  h! E, Z3 B! e- G0 R9 z. a4 m, i2 E
我覺得西藥重...
1 ?/ q* `8 t) ?) [我聽人講都係咁講
作者: zlkwa    時間: 2005-6-4 02:34 PM

其實西藥好唔好咁就見仁見智......0 D2 v2 M# M- _6 J1 t# m: S
d西藥年中都唔知食死幾多人.....又話有咩副作用...
: ^0 t6 R; Y0 U+ H: j, c# [不如食中藥.......話曬都幾千年歷史....# h# ~+ m& S" c4 p4 N8 H
"經驗,呃唔到人ge"
作者: yeahchan    時間: 2005-6-4 04:16 PM

我覺得各有各好~
0 l- J# o# R, m* u: H$ }我會睇完西醫醫好之後睇中醫調理身子~
( M! d  f7 R. D一時時自己覺得濕重, 熱氣都會去睇中醫!!!
作者: secretfj    時間: 2005-6-5 10:23 PM

我自己有感冒, 阿媽一定捉我去睇中醫...
" A- i' f( X: a2 E+ x" ~不過又好有效就是了(苦茶難入口是中藥的另一大問題..)0 v% m" }3 v8 [

% V  K( G4 l; i& h0 f; Y西方醫術對急病非常有效 (e.g. Trauma, Heart Attack, Stroke等)3 B& K1 T& I3 m$ s1 o0 I; w
中醫就對身體的小毛病或長期病較有效
$ S) l+ P/ b" Y2 m* u# L9 J) u( z) z+ `9 {* ~
In General,
3 Z( l) t. u; v$ |西醫著重用外力消除毛病(e.g. 流鼻水就收鼻水)
4 K+ a8 p" x$ C: F中醫就靠固本培元, 讓身體好起來, 自行把毛病趕走 8 U3 Y9 e+ W! @& h0 a$ C( v, p

4 U5 V2 @$ R& N/ v5 ^不過要講清楚的是, 傷風感冒食藥係香港呢D咁忙0既地方至會用(得閒死唔得閒病)% r  Z; c) h- ]* Q
外國的醫生多是叫你多喝水, 多休息, 多給你幾天病假讓你好好休養# N, C2 r$ Y4 B+ d

% {/ l; U( y1 U. t[ Last edited by secretfj on 2005-6-5 at 10:25 PM ]
作者: forty40forty    時間: 2005-6-5 11:14 PM     標題: 中醫vs西醫:一場沒有句號的爭論

中藥和西藥的不同。/ [! f* I% G7 L$ A0 y4 a. o3 L

7 h- B1 e5 ]8 N
9 z. Y" N' R& v7 p: s5 U2 b    有人如此形容中藥和西藥間的不同:中藥是隨身量做
" G3 }4 D6 t* O% N/ d8 Y2 R的衣服,西藥則是大量訂做的製服。也就是說,中藥是針
" J& h5 Q5 P9 r) C* a% b對各種不同病症及病患的不同體質來給藥,而西藥則只是( D) [" D* U; @4 e% k& t, p& S
針對病症來給藥。因而,中藥對人體的副作用大都小於西
, t7 t! K% t, _4 H+ o藥對人體的副作用。
& x  b9 J5 N/ ?: A. I$ J
- d# z- b) X! U% Q# ?- z. t; O1 ^8 ]+ a, z3 n  T
    中藥和西藥的另一不同在於:中藥在以提高病患的扺
& R( W1 x/ P/ r! @. J' J+ _抗力,讓其自行殺滅病菌;而西藥則是以殺死病菌為己任。
3 k/ c- D/ [  B" v' U因而,中藥雖藥性緩慢卻有治本的功效;西藥則是藥性快$ H/ n1 C; t# y0 }
速,卻只能治標。




歡迎光臨 娛樂滿紛 26FUN (http://26fun.com/bbs7/) Powered by Discuz! 7.0.0