brightlee

尤其中眉底彈落黎果d波, 我敢講10個球正10個都係斷估....

As I am referee, I can tell you about this situation

Normally, I would look at the linesmen to confirm it's a goal or not
cos as referee, they will stay outside the penalty box except Penalty or Corner (even that's corner, referee should stay after penalty spot to have a board view

brightlee

I watch the highlight show again. If I was Rob Styles and stood in that position
I would give a penalty to Chelsea

Cos I saw Finnan was trying to take a really bad tackle, the Chelsea player was jumping up to prevent it.....

It's still a foul, remember a foul is a foul, couldn't escape........

Similar situation as C. Ronaldo was sent off by Steve Bennett 2 years ago when Man City vs Man Utd. C. Ronaldo didn't touch Andrew Cole, but that's definity a foul ... a professional foul, straight RED

brightlee

Originally posted by eqhigh at 2007-8-20 23:25:


佢解釋番話...第二張黃牌係比泰利...

haha... upcoming news from soccernet!!!!

Referees' chief Keith Hackett has confirmed Rob Styles will not take charge of a match next weekend after his performance in the game between Liverpool and Chelsea at Anfield on Sunday.

Rob Styles and Jamie Carragher
Allsport
Jamie Carragher has words with Rob Styles after his controversial penalty decision.

Styles controversially awarded Chelsea a penalty which enabled the Blues to equalise after Fernando Torres' opener, before causing confusion by brandishing a yellow card at Michael Essien - who had already been booked - but insisting it was John Terry being booked.

And Hackett, general manager of Professional Game Match Officials Limited, told Sky Sports: 'Accountability exists and we, the PGMOL, do expect referees to get big decisions correct.

'On this occasion it was wrong and therefore Rob will not be officiating next weekend.'

Hackett also revealed assistant referee Ian Gosling will be given next weekend off, after he denied Fulham a late goal at home to Middlesbrough when David Healy clearly forced the ball over the line.

The referees' supremo even apologised to Rafael Benitez and Lawrie Sanchez - Liverpool and Fulham manager respectively.

On Styles, Hackett added: 'I spoke to Rob this morning and obviously he is extremely disappointed with the decision and admitted he got it wrong. I have left a message with Rafael Benitez to apologise.

'Having looked at a video and seen a better angle and a better view, clearly he (Styles) now recognises that he got it wrong and he's deeply apologetic for that. I think, in fact, he too will be making contact with Liverpool in order to offer his apologies.'

Asked about the confusion when Essien appeared to be booked for a second time, Hackett said: 'I'm informed by both the fourth official and Rob he retained the card shown to John Terry then held the card to indicate a direct free-kick, and failed to put the card away. So it was a basic, if you like, admin error as against an error in application of law.

'We'll look at the video to ensure we don't get a repeat of that.'

Hackett also confirmed Gosling, who wrongly ruled Boro goalkeeper Mark Schwarzer prevented Healy's effort from crossing the line, will also be without a game this weekend.

'Clearly the assistant referee has made an error, so he won't be operating next week for us either.'

brightlee

Originally posted by filter-052fans at 2007-8-21 02:50:


即使你係球証, 我都不同意果一球...

I am not saying you are wrong

I think that's not a penalty if I watched from TV.

of cos, from TV view, we are sure that's no foul at all,
But if you look at the view of referee, that's difference, cos he'd run 90 degree opposite than TV, and he'd run on the ground level.
Linesmen couldn't help in this situation, cos he was standing on the same side as referee.
That's why he admitted he was wrong ... (from soccernet) as he viewed that incident with different angles.

Sometimes that's life... I think the TV technology is good .. but the only one question in my mind is, will the game get a lot of delays when all the players are complaining some decision?

brightlee

Originally posted by eqhigh at 2007-8-20 23:25:


佢解釋番話...第二張黃牌係比泰利...

i want to see that action

it's not showing in highlight show....

brightlee

Originally posted by filter-052fans at 2007-8-21 18:25:


從來我唔怪球証會睇錯, 因為不竟係人...
連醫學報告都話, 球証無可能判斷到offside既

I can tell you, that's absolutely right


Sometimes I may guess when I am Assistant Referee

brightlee

Originally posted by filter-052fans at 2007-8-21 18:25:


似乎國際足協視若無睹...哈哈

Yes, I think so........ but on the other hand... they may change a lot of procedure for the power of referees..etc......

Anyway, let Fifa to make this decision


[ Last edited by brightlee on 2007-8-21 at 07:09 PM ]

brightlee

Originally posted by 20001160 at 2007-8-21 18:04:

其實有無留意球證企係邊     
留意左你就明點解佢會吹
芬倫   馬路逹     球證  成一直線        
而佢兩個有無接觸係佢個位置係睇唔到

Not exactly straight line... but Rob Styles was running really close to straight line, and that's what I want to point out!!!

cos when I watched at highlight show, the first thing I was looking the position of referee and linesman!

Few weeks ago, I was watching the church soccer game. The referee gave a free kick outside the penalty spot. I was standing left side (outside) of the field, I didn't agree his decision. But when I saw he was running 'on the straight line' .... about 50 yards away for that incident, I understood why he made that decision.

The referee did the 'right' things, and it'd in counter attack, the referee was running as quick as possible in that stage.. (but still 50 yards away....
)

brightlee

Originally posted by filter-052fans at 2007-8-21 18:25:


至少唔會出現艾辛2黃不紅既攪笑情況,
個人推測果晚太多野係, 史泰奧斯唔夠肯定情況下判決,
最後吹完自己也無信心, 進退失據, 最後亂晒大龍...

I didn't see that match, but I can tell you if he'd be scary about making decision, it'd be normal.
Any soccer players, or fans, may never know how much pressure for the referee is until he/she becomes referees one day.  

That's what I see about many players try to become referees in my church league this year. Players (referee) thought it'd be easy, so they never goto study the training course. Then at the end, they become crept on the field