brightlee

I asked the referee coach during meeting today,
this is his answer

If it's similar as what Space2007 was describing about, that'd be onside

But what I saw, that's different than your view (cos in highlight show, they showed an angle really closed to linesman, p.s. I may be wrong

The situation what I saw is:

front view
                 GK
(left)                                    (right)
             A         A
                                      A
            D            D

When the right winger cross the ball with forward position like that, that's Offside.

[ Last edited by brightlee on 2007-9-19 at 10:22 PM ]

saronabc

it is clear offside as the right winger pass the ball across and the striker was in front of him with no defenders on hand whatsoever

brightlee

Originally posted by saronabc at 2007-9-19 21:45:
it is clear offside as the right winger pass the ball across and the striker was in front of him with no defenders on hand whatsoever

That's what I watched in Highlight show too!
But you know... that's no any replay we can see in internet so can't filter-004 for this.

SPACE2007

其實個晚睇的時候, 有唔同的角度去睇呢球波, 其中一個角度, 按球場上草地的顏色, 可看到巴列堤係前過卡勞,

不過呢個都唔緊要, 主要個point 係越位的規例係點, 即係brightlee版主的意思是, 只要傳球球員係前過接應球員, 不論前面還有沒有對方球或者個球係向前, 平衡或後傳, 都不算越位, 係唔係?

brightlee

Originally posted by SPACE2007 at 2007-9-19 23:54:
其實個晚睇的時候, 有唔同的角度去睇...

Yes you are right. cos the one who 'cross' the ball, break the offside trip already

brightlee

p.s. let's learn together

SPACE2007

係呀, 大家一齊研究, 唔係拗, 氣氛幾好呀!!

其實我應該利益申報, 我係車仔忠實Fans, 由荷度年代開始ga !!!!!!!!!

brightlee

you know, I am referee nowadays, I am not a fans for any team now....

By the way, I start to watch Chelsea in Kerry Dixon's day.....

[ Last edited by brightlee on 2007-9-20 at 12:19 AM ]

SPACE2007

嘩, 咁我又後過你好多喎!!

Anyway, all of us can filter-004 in the future.